Table of Contents:

Concluding remarks

While tourism scholars and practitioners tend to assign positive values to visits of cultural heritage as “a shared common good by which everyone benefits” (Silverman and Ruggles, 2007, p. 3), the examples in this chapter provide evidence of the contentious entanglement of heritage tourism with universalist cultural ideologies, state power and localised abuse of human rights. The case of Guatemala’s Maya Biosphere Reserve shows how contrasting visions about tourism, heritage conservation and environmental protection can lead to entrenched conflicts between communities and other actors, in this case archaeologists, corporations, drug barons, the national government and politicians from a foreign power. The case studies from China demonstrate how the designation of World Heritage Sites and associated tourism developments have led to restrictions on traditional livelihood activities and the resettlement of populations, resulting in protracted tensions between the government, corporate actors and local communities. The case of the Angkor Archaeological Park in Cambodia testifies to the colonial legacies of cultural heritage management and shows how the interpretations and regulations imposed by non-Cambodians (e.g. UNESCO, bilateral donors, Western archaeologists) marginalises contemporary Cambodian culture, silences local voices, and infringes on local residents’ rights to property and adequate housing. The inherent conflict between universal heritage and local rights is also evidenced in the cases of Buenos Aires’ La Boca district and the ancient Inca capital Cuzco where a combination of violent state-led gentrification and market forces has evicted

Cultural heritage tourism 161 residents and informal vendors from the city centres to the urban fringes. Their livelihoods have become increasingly precarious due to the lack of basic amenities and economic opportunities.

Such processes of gentrification are further examined in the next chapter which discusses how sports mega-events and large-scale tourism infrastructure projects for airports and railways have been used to legitimise urban ‘beautification’ schemes, forced land acquisitions and involuntary resettlements. Examples from South Africa, Brazil, India, Laos and Mexico will show the destructive impacts such processes have had on local livelihoods and cultures.

References

Adams, V., van Hattum, T. and English, D. (2009) ‘Chronic disaster syndrome: Displacement, disaster capitalism, and the eviction of the poor from New Orleans’, American Ethnologist, 36 (4): 615-636.

Ashworth, G., Graham, B. and Tunbridge, J. (2007) Pluralising Pasts: Heritage, Identity and Place in Multicultural Societies. Pluto: London.

Betancur, J.J. (2014) ‘Gentrification in Latin America: Overview and critical analysis’, Urban Studies Research, 4: 1-14.

Bocci, C., Fortman, L., Solingen, B. and Millian, B. (2018) ‘The impact of community' forest concessions on income: an analysis of communities in the Maya Biosphere Reserve’, World Development, 107: 10—21.

Bromley, R.D.F. and Mackie, P.K. (2009) ‘Displacement and the new spaces for informal trade in the Latin American city centre’, Urban Studies, 46 (7): 1485-1506.

Chan, J.H., lankova, K., Zhang, Y., McDonald, T. and Qi, X. (2016) ‘The role ofself-gentrification in sustainable tourism: Indigenous entrepreneurship at Honghe Hani Rice Terraces World Heritage Site, China’, Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 24 (8—9): 1262-1279.

Chion, M. (2009) ‘Cambios en el centro histórico del Cuzco: espacios turísticos, espacios culturales [Changes in the historic centre of Cuzco: tourist spaces, cultural spaces]’ in Nieto Degregori, L. (ed.) El ombligo se pone piercing: Identidad, patrimonio у cambios en al Cuzco [The Navel Gets Pierced: Identity', Heritage and Changes in Cuzco]. Centro Guarnan Poma de Ayala: Lima, pp. 115-150.

Cocola-Gant, A. (2018) ‘Tourism gentrification’ in Lees, L. and Phillips, M. (eds) Handbook of Gentrification Studies. Edward Elgar Publishing: Cheltenham, Northampton, pp. 281-293.

Devine, J. (2014) ‘Counterinsurgency ecotourism in Guatemala’s May'a Biosphere Reserve’, Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, 32: 984—1001.

Devine, J. (2017) ‘Colonizing space and commodifying place: Tourism’s violent geographies’, Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 25 (5): 634—650.

Devine, J. and Ojeda, D. (2017) ‘Violence and dispossession in tourism development: A critical geographical approach’, Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 25 (5): 605-617.

Devine, J.A., Wrathall, D., Currit, N.. Tellman, B. and Langarica, Y.R. (2020) ‘Narco-cattle ranching in political forests’, Antipode, 52 (4): 1018-1038.

Fiiller, H. and Michel, B. (2014) “‘Stop being a tourist!” New dynamics of urban tourism in Berlin-Kreuzberg’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 38 (4): 1304-1318.

Gaffney, C. (2016) ‘Gentrifications in pre-Olympic Rio de Janeiro’, Urban Geography, 37: 1132-1153.

Gao, J., Lin, H. and Zhang, C. (2020) ‘Locally situated rights and the “doing” of responsibility for heritage conservation and tourism development at the cultural landscape of Honghe Hani Rice Terraces, China’, Journal of Sustainable Tourism. doi: 10.1080/09669582.2020.1727912.

Garcia, P. (2020) ‘Indigeneity in the air: The case of Chinchero airport in Cusco, Peru’, Bulletin of Latin American Research, 39 (2): 157—171.

Gillespie, J. (2009) ‘Protecting world heritage: Regulating ownership and land use at Angkor Archaeological Park, Cambodia’, International Journal of Heritage Studies, 15 (4): 338-354.

Gillespie, J. (2011) ‘Legal pluralism and world heritage management at Angkor, Cambodia’, Asia-Pacific Journal of Environmental Law, 14 (1&2): 1-19.

Gladstone, D. and Préau, J. (2008) ‘Gentrification in tourism cities: evidence from New Orleans before and after Hurricane Katrina’, Housing Policy Debate, 19 (1): 137—175.

Gobierno de la Ciudad Autónoma de Buenos Aires (2017) Transformación del Distrito [Transformation of the District]. Available at: www.buenosaires.gob.ar/distritodelasa rtes/transformacion-deldistrito (accessed 16 February 2019).

Herzer, H. (2010) Con el corazon mirando al sur: Transformaciones en el sur de la ciudad de Buenos Aires [With the Heart Looking Southward: Transformations in the South of the City of Buenos Aires], Espacio Editorial: Buenos Aires.

Heikilla, EJ. and Peycam, P. (2010) ‘Economic development in the shadow of Angkor Wat: Meaning, legitimation, and myth’, Journal of Planning Education and Research, 29 (3): 294-309.

International Tribunal of Evictions (2017) Case from Argentina, Buenos Aires: Evictions and gentrification in the historic and tourist neighbourhood La Boca. Available at: www.tribunal-evictions.org/international_tribunal_on_evictions/evictions_cases/6th_ session_2017/case_from_argentina_buenos_aires_evictions_and_gentrification_in_the _historic_and_tourist_neighbourhood_la_boca (accessed 16 February 2019).

1WG1A and FPP (2015) Promotion and protection of the rights of indigenous peoples with respect to their cultural heritage in the context of the implementation of UNESCO’s World Heritage Convention. Available at: www.ohchr.org/Docum ents/Issues/IPeoples/EMRIP/CulturalHeritage/IWGlA.pdf (accessed 12 November 2018).

Janoschka, M. and Sequera, J. (2016) ‘Gentrification in Latin America: Addressing the politics and geographies of displacement’, Urban Geography, 37 (8): 1175-1194.

Jones, G.A. and Varley, A. (1999) ‘The reconquest of the historic centre: urban conservation and gentrification in Puebla, Mexico’, Environment and Planning A, 31 (9): 1547-1566.

Knight, D.W., Cottrell, S.P., Pickering, K., Bohren, L. and Bright, A. (2017) ‘Tourism-based development in Cusco, Peru: Comparing national discourses with local realities’, Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 25 (3): 344—361.

Li, Y., Lau, C. and Su, P. (2020) ‘Heritage tourism stakeholder conflict: A case of a World Heritage Site in China’, Journal of Tourism and Cultural Change, 18 (3): 267-287.

Logan, J. and Molotoch, H. (2007) Urban Fortunes: The Political Economy of Place (2nd edition). University' of California: Berkeley, Los Angeles.

Luciano, P.A. (2017) ‘Where are the edges of a protected area? Political dispossession in Machu Picchu, Peru’, Conservation and Society, 9 (10): 35-41.

Lunstrum, E. and Ybarra, M. (2018) ‘Deploying difference: security threat narratives and state displacement from protected areas’, Conservation and Society, 16 (2): 114—124.

Miura, K. (2011a) ‘World heritage making in Angkor: Global, regional, national and local actors, interplays and implications’ in Hauser-Scháublin, B. (ed.) World Heritage Angkor and Beyond: Circumstances and Implications of UNESCO Listings in Cambodia. Gottingen University Press: Gottingen, pp. 9-31.

Miura, K. (2011b) ‘Sustainable development in Angkor: Conservation regime of the old villagescape and development’ in Hauser-Schaublin, B. (ed.) World Heritage Angkor and Beyond: Circumstances and Implications of UNESCO Listings in Cambodia. Gottingen University Press: Gottingen, pp. 121-144.

Mowforth, M. and Munt, 1. (2016) Tourism and Sustainability: Development, Globalisation and Neu> Tourism in the Third World (4th edition). Routledge: London, New York.

Rahder (2015) ‘But is it a basin? Science, controversy, and conspiracy in the fight for Mirador, Guatemala’, Science as Culture, 24 (3): 299-324.

Rodríguez, M.C. and Di Virgilio, M.M. (2016) ‘A city for all? Public policy and resistance to gentrification in the southern neighborhoods of Buenos Aires’, Urban Geography, 37 (8): 1215-1234.

Rodríguez, M.C., Mejica, S.A., Rodríguez, M.F., Gómez Schettini, M. and Zapata, M.C. (2011) ‘La política urbana “PRO”: Continuidades y cambios en contextos de renovación en la ciudad de Buenos Aires [The urban policy “PRO”: continuities and changes in the contexts of renewal in the city of Buenos Aires]’, Cuaderno Urbano, 1 (1): 81-101.

Rojas, E. (1999) Old Cities, New Assets: Preserving Latin America’s Urban Heritage. Inter-American Development Bank: Washington, DC.

Sequera, J. and Rodríguez, T. (2017) ‘Turismo, abandono y desplazamiento: Mapeando el barrio de La Boca en Buenos Aires [Tourism, abandonment and displacement: Mapping the La Boca neighbourhood in Buenos Aires]’, Journal of Latin American Geography, 16 (1): 117-137.

Silverman, H. and Ruggles, D.F. (2007) ‘Cultural heritage and human rights’ in Silverman, H. and Ruggles, D.F. (eds.) Cultural Heritage and Human Rights. Springer: New York, pp. 3-22.

Steel, G. (2013) ‘Mining and tourism: Urban transformations in the intermediate cities of Cajamarca and Cusco, Peru’, Latin American Perspectives, 40 (2): 237-249.

Su, M.M., Wall, G. and Xu, K. (2016) ‘Heritage tourism and livelihood sustainability of a resettled rural community: Mount Sanqingshan World Heritage Site, China’, Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 24 (5): 735-757.

Timothy, D.J. (2015) ‘Cultural heritage, tourism and socio-economic development’ in Sharpley, R. and Telfer, DJ. (eds) Tourism and Development: Concepts and Issues (2nd edition). Channel View Publications: Bristol, Buffalo, Toronto, pp. 237—249.

US Congress (2019) S.3131 - Mirador-Calakmul Basin Maya Security and Conservation Partnership Act of 2019. Available at: www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/sena te-bill/3131/text (accessed 10 July 2020).

Wang, L. and Yotsumoto, Y. (2019) ‘Conflict in tourism development in rural China’, Tourism Management, 70: 188-200.

Winter, T. (2007) Post-Conflict Heritage, Postcolonial 'Tourism: Culture, Politics and Development at Angkor. Routledge: London, New York.

Wong, L.K.W. (2017) Urban Transformations in Latin America's Cultural Capital: An Analysis of City Branding and its Impact on Gentrification in Buenos Aires. Masters Thesis in Latin American Studies, Leiden University, Leiden.

Zhang, C., Fyall, A. and Zheng, Y. (2015) ‘Heritage and tourism conflict within world heritage sites in China: A longitudinal study’, Current Issues in Tourism, 18 (2): 110-136.

Media sources/websites

Cheng, S. (2019) ‘Angkor hosts 2.6M visitors’, Phnom Penh Post, 2 January. Available at: www.phnompenhpost.com/business/angkor-hosts-26m-visitors (accessed 18 February 2019).

Collyns, 1). (2019) “‘It would destroy it”: new international airport for Machu Picchu sparks outrage’, The Guardian, 15 May. Available at: www.theguardian.com/cities/20 19/may/15/archaeologists-outraged-over-plans-for-machu-picchu-airport-chinchero (accessed 12 July 2020).

Cuffe, S. (2016) ‘Controversial park plans in Guatemala’s Maya Biosphere Reserve’, Mongohay, 17 June. Available at: https://news.mongabay.com/2016/06/controversia 1-park-plans-in-guatemalas-maya-biosphere-reserve/ (Accessed on 9 February 2019).

García, B. (2020) ‘The suspicious initiative of an archaeologist to “save” an ancient Mayan city’, Al Día, 18 June. Available at: https://aldianews.com/articles/culture/ social/suspicious-initiative-archaeologist-save-ancient-mayan-city/58920 (accessed 12 July 2020).

Kaliyann, T. (2013) ‘Eco village attracts homestay tourist dollars’, Phnom Penh Post, 12 August. Available at: www.phnompenhpost.com/siem-reap-insider/eco-village-attra cts-homestay-tourist-dollars (accessed 18 February 2019).

Maya Biosphere Watch (2020) ‘U.S. senators draft legislation that infringes on land rights in Guatemala and Mexico’, 4 January'. Available at: https://mayabiospherewatch.com/u-s-senators-draft-legislation-that-infringes-on-land-rights-in-guatemala-and-mexico/ (accessed 12 July 2020).

Pearce, F. (2020) ‘Parks vs. people: In Guatemala, communities take best care of the forest’, Yale Environment 360, 18 June. Available at: https://e360.yale.edu/features/pa rks-vs-people-in-guatemala-communities-take-best-care-of-the-forest (accessed 12 July 2020).

Pech, S. (2017a) ‘Forces demolish illegal homes in Angkor park’, Khmer Times, 20 June.

Available at: www.khmertimeskh.com/news/39476/forces-demolish-illegal-homes-i n-angkor-park/ (accessed 18 February 2019).

Pech, S. (2017b) ‘Illegal building at Angkor site must go, says Unesco’, Khmer Times, 27 June. Available at: www.khmertimeskh.com/news/39692/illegal-building-at-a ngkor-site-must-go—says-unesco/ (accessed 18 February 2019).

UNESCO (n.d.) ‘Biosphere Reserves - Learning Sites for Sustainable Development’. Available at: www.unesco.org/new/en/natural-sciences/environment/ecological-sci ences/biosphere-reserves/ (accessed 12 February 2019).

UNESCO (n.d.) ‘City of Cuzco’. Available at: https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/273 (accessed 12 February 2019).

 
Source
< Prev   CONTENTS   Source   Next >