Contributions of G, E and GEI Effects for DRT and BMQ Traits

The contributions of genotype (G) and environment (E) main-effects can be preliminarily judged by ANOVA (Tsilo et al. 2011; Li et al. 2013); however, its third component could include the GEI effects and the error. The Additive main effects and multiplicative interaction (AMMI) analysis (Nachit et al. 1992) combines additive and multivariate approaches and improves the analysis of non-additive GEI effects. In our studies on the HI977 × HD2329 population, LV indicated the highest contribution from G (38 %). However, for all the traits, either E (47–74 %) or GEI (42–57

%) were the main contributors. AMMI analysis showed 6–47 % contribution from GEI to total variation in terms of 1 to 4 principal component axes (Prashant et al. 2015). Similarly, Hristov et al. (2010) showed significant GEI contribution to LV, SV and GPC by AMMI analysis. It is possible that GEI could influence correlations among LV and its predictive tests thereby making it necessary to examine them individually in year-location combinations.

Trait Correlations and the Influence of the Environment

Using the average of the data from different years and locations (environments) to calculate trait correlations masks the effect of GEI and suppresses the patterns of trait inter-relationships across environments (Tsilo et al. 2011; Li et al. 2012). Mann et al. (2009) evaluated genetic correlations among DRT and BMQ traits in three

Fig. 33.1 Pattern of correlations among dough rheological traits, loaf volume, SDS-sedimentation volume and grain protein content in HI977 × HD2329 population. nsnon-significant

individual environments that indicated consistent negative correlation between Maximum height of the Extensograph curve and LV. However, the stability of the correlations across multiple years in different locations could not be conclusively assessed since data were recorded at two locations, but in single year in one of them. We could efficiently document the repeatability of the correlations among LV, GPC, SV and DRT in HI977 × HD2329 RIL population as we assessed them in six individual year-location environments (Fig. 33.1). We found that correlations between 15 mixograph trait pairs were highly consistent since they were significant in five or in all the six environments. Among the rest, significant correlations were observed in one to four environments. MRI and MPT with LV and EPI, MRI and MPT with SV were significant in three environments and were the only DRT-BMQ trait pairs that showed fairly consistent correlations. However, majority of the correlations that were significant in only one or two environments involved LV, SV or GPC. Eleven trait pairs showed correlations that were inconsistent since they were positive or negative in different year-locations (Prashant et al. 2015). The environmental influence on correlations between predictive tests and LV, as well as significant GEI contributions suggested that even if a QTL with high contribution to predictive tests is detected, its stability across environments is important if it has to be considered for use in MAS for LV.

Clustering and Location-Specificity of BMQ and DRT QTLs

Composite Interval Mapping (CIM) determined QTLs on all the chromosomes of bread wheat for LV, GPC, SV and DRT (Li et al. 2012; El-Feki et al. 2013; references therein). In addition, QTL clusters mainly for GPC, SV and DRT (Li et al.2012) and for DRT and LV (Mann et al. 2009; Tsilo et al. 2011; Simons et al. 2012) suggested that as the traits are correlated, they could be controlled by common QTLs. But it needs to be noted that the HMW glutenin loci Glu-B1 or Glu-D1 often showed overlap with the largest of such clusters for DRT and LV and suggested that extensive studies to identify novel loci on other chromosomes are necessary for further improvement of wheat quality. In our analyses on HI977 ×HD2329 population, 158 QTLs for LV, SV, GPC and DRT were identified with 9–46 % contribution to phenotypic variance. There were 16 QTL clusters on nine chromosomes with co-locating QTLs for four to seven traits. Only a single QTL cluster on chromosome 5B showed co-location for LV and DRT.

In many of the previous studies, large number of DRT and BMQ QTLs were detected in single environments (Mann et al. 2009; Tsilo et al. 2011; Li et al. 2012; Simons et al. 2012) and stable QTLs were very few, which often co-located with HMW glutenin loci (Mann et al. 2009; Tsilo et al. 2011). Examining their specificity to individual locations and pattern of detection across years within a location can help reveal their responses to GEI. In our study, 69 % of the QTLs were identified in single environments and only 15 % were detected in three or more environments. The significant influence of GEI was reflected in the pattern in which QTLs were detected across environments. We identified 109 QTLs for the traits analyzed, which were specifically expressed in single years in Karnal, Kota and Pune (Fig. 33.2).

Fig. 33.2 Location-specificity of QTLs for dough rheological traits, loaf volume, SDSsedimentation volume and grain protein content detected in single years in HI977 × HD2329 population

Interestingly, majority of them (47 %) were specific to Karnal and the rest were equally distributed in other two locations. In addition, the individual traits showed differential location-specificity for such QTLs. Furthermore, when the QTLs expressed in two or more environments were examined, 62 % showed expression in consecutive years in Karnal, followed by 34 % in Kota and only 4 % at Pune (Prashant et al. 2015).


The GEI contributions, trait correlations and QTL clusters reinforce the view that wheat quality is achieved by complex gene repertoire and action underlying the levels and composition of grain constituents. The QTL clusters provide leads for characterization of genomic regions controlling end-use quality traits in wheat. In the coming years, genetic maps with better resolution and the wheat genome sequence would help resolve pleiotropic gene effects and multiple genes with close linkage. The location-specificity of QTLs detected in both single-environment and across years in HI977 × HD2329 population suggested that for traits exhibiting high GEI, it might be beneficial to target specific agro-climatic zones while breeding varieties for quality traits. In addition, QTL validation in those zones in multiple years using many wheat genotypes is necessary for their use in MAS.

Acknowledgments We gratefully acknowledge the Department of Biotechnology (DBT), Government of India for financial support for this work and Bio-CARe Fellowship for RP and the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research, Government of India research fellowships for RP and EM. We thank Drs. Meena Lagu and Bhushan Dholakia, CSIR-NCL, Pune, for help in planning the experiment and Dr. Marion Röder, IPK, Gatersleben, Germany, for facilitating SSR genotyping of the HI977 × HD2329 population.

< Prev   CONTENTS   Next >