My internist is prescribing an antidepressant. How do I know whether I should see a specialist? Should I see a psychopharmacologist?

A general practitioner of medicine can often adequately treat depression. There are situations, however, when a psychiatric consultation should be obtained. If there are comorbid conditions such as anxiety or substance abuse, severe suicidal thinking, or complicated personality issues, a psychiatrist is better equipped to manage the antidepressant treatment. In particular, the psychiatrist may be able to provide more frequent contacts and have longer sessions than the general practitioner typically has available. One problem that arises, however, when depression is treated by a general practitioner is that under-dosing of medication is more common, as well as too short of a duration of treatment. Certainly, if the depression is not responding to a prescribed treatment, consultation with a specialist is warranted as well. Some individuals seek the services of a psychopharmacologist. The term can be somewhat misleading, because it implies a specialty in medication management of psychiatric conditions. In fact, all general psychiatrists are adequately trained in pharmacotherapy of mental disorders and need not be designated as psychopharmacologists. Some psychiatrists restrict their practice to medication management of mental disorders and thus are self-described as psychopharmacologists. Psychiatrists are available who develop more expertise in the management of certain conditions and use of some medications, by virtue of clinical experience and perhaps research in academic settings, and thus may take referrals from other psychiatrists (and mental health clinicians) for more refractory conditions. In general, however, seeking consultation from a general psychiatrist is usually appropriate for most emotional problems. Specialists may be sought within the field of psychiatry for treatment of children and adolescents (child and adolescent psychiatrist), older people (geriatric psychiatrist), people who are medically ill (consultation-liaison psychiatrist), and individuals with substance abuse (addiction psychiatrist).

Why do I need a mood stabilizer with my antidepressant if I am depressed but not manic?

"Mood stabilizer" has a variety of meanings attached to it. For the lay public, any medication that helps even one's moods, including the antidepressant medications, is a mood stabilizer. For most psychiatrists, mood stabilizer[1] includes a class of medications that treat and prevent mania. These medications typically include anticonvulsant medications such as valproic acid and carbamazepine; atypical antipsychotic medications such as olanzapine, quetiapine, risperidone, and aripiprazole; and lithium. However, the definition of a true mood stabilizer is a medication that treats and prevents both depression and mania. No true mood stabilizer by that definition exists. Perhaps lithium is the closest to meeting that definition, although it does not truly compare with antidepressants in effectively treating depression. Other antimanic medications that are never thought of as mood stabilizers include the anti-anxiety medications. At one time, alprazolam was used to treat certain forms of depression as well as anxiety and mania.

Thus it is important to understand that when a psychiatrist adds a mood stabilizer to an antidepressant, one needs to know exactly what class of agent is being prescribed and for what purpose. Many times patients may have associated symptoms with their depression (such as psychosis) and therefore an atypical antipsychotic medication is an appropriate addition to the antidepressant. Still other patients may experience a great deal of anxiety and panic, in which case the addition of an antianxiety agent may be appropriate. Some patients may never have had a manic episode, but some of their symptoms and family history are strongly suggestive of an underlying bipolar disorder. Under these circumstances the safest medication to prescribe may be a mood stabilizer alone, unless the depression is severe enough to warrant aggressive care, in which case the psychiatrist may prescribe an antidepressant with an anticonvulsant, lithium, or atypical antipsychotic as a preventative measure. Finally, some patients may achieve only a partial response to the antidepressant. When a partial response is achieved, the psychiatrist will typically add another medication to augment the primary medication's response rather than switch the medication altogether. Aripiprazole has an FDA indication for use as an augmenting agent to antidepressant medication for the treatment of major depression.

  • [1] typically refers to medications for the treatment and prevention of mood swings, such as from depression to mania.
< Prev   CONTENTS   Next >