Savings can be achieved by cutting compensation costs and/or by reducing the workforce
Compensation costs can be lowered by reducing the size of the workforce and/or cutting wages. While government employment across the OECD has generally been stable over the past decade, at least 17 governments across the OECD have announced workforce reduction measures and/or cuts to salaries and benefits in order to cut costs. On average, governments in OECD member countries employ 15% of the labour force. The size of the Slovenian public sector is very close to the OECD average, with the share of employment in general government at 14.7% of the labour force (OECD, 2011c) (see Figure 1.9).
In some OECD member countries, public sector employment will be scaled back considerably (see Table 1.1). The Czech Republic plans to remove 10% of the public workforce, excluding teachers. By 2014, there should be 330 000 fewer public sector employees in the United Kingdom and around 25 000 fewer in Ireland. Other countries (France, Greece, Portugal and Spain) will only replace a certain number of vacant positions or retiring employees (OECD, 2011d). Slovenia reports a planned 1% reduction across the board of public sector employees. It should be noted that staff reduction plans fall outside the scope of the OECD’s review of
Slovenia’s public sector salary system, but are discussed in detail as part of the broader Public Governance Review.
Table 1.1. Staff reduction targets in selected OECD member countries
Country |
Reductions |
Austria |
3 000 federal officials by 2014 |
France |
97 000 public sector jobs by only replacing 1 of 2 retiring state employees |
Germany |
10 000 federal public sector jobs by 2014 |
Greece |
20% of retiring employees replaced, fewer public short-term contract employees |
Ireland |
24 750 public sector jobs by 2014 |
Portugal |
Recruitment freeze of civil servants (no replacements) |
Slovenia |
1% of public sector employees from 2010-2011 |
Spain |
10% replacement of vacant positions between 2011 and 2013 |
United Kingdom |
330 000 public sector jobs by 2014 |
Source: OECD (2011), “Restoring Public Finances”, Special issue of the OECD Journal on Budgeting, 2011/2, OECD Publishing, Paris.
OECD data on remuneration for key public sector positions show that wages and salaries represent, on average, 80% of total compensation. Twenty OECD member countries have announced plans to freeze or cut public sector wages. The range of wage cuts is wide and crosses categories of countries, from a two-year wage freeze in the United Kingdom to a 10% wage cut in the Czech Republic, and approximately a 14% wage reduction in Ireland (see Table 1.2). The cutbacks are even higher in Greece if reductions in allowances and earlier implemented cuts from 2009 and 2010 are included. The total quantified wage reduction is between 0.6% of GDP and more than 0.8% of GDP in Hungary, Ireland and Portugal (see Figure 1.11B) (OECD, 2011d). Slovenia reports a 14% wage and intermediate public consumption cut.
In addition, government (as an employer) contributes to retirement plans or pensions, and private health insurance costs or other social contributions. Thus, reforms to the pension and health systems could also have important effects on government compensation costs. However, changes in these areas may be more difficult to implement for current staff, as they involve altering long-term contracts. It should be noted: while pension and health systems form part of government compensation costs, they are not within the scope of this review.
Table 1.2. Wage reduction targets in selected OECD member countries
Country |
Reductions |
Belgium |
0.7% savings on personnel expenditures |
Czech Republic |
10% wage cut in the public sector (excluding teachers) |
Estonia |
9% savings on personnel expenditures |
France |
Freezing public sector wages in 2011 |
Greece |
Allowances cut by 20% in 2010 Abolishing the 13th and 14th month bonuses for monthly earnings above EUR 3 000 (=14%) |
Ireland |
13.5% public sector wage cut in 2009-2010; more cuts expected in 2011-2014 |
Portugal |
5% wage cut in the public sector, 0.11% to 0.84% of GDP wage cut by 2013 |
Slovak Republic |
10% wage cut in central government |
Spain |
5% wage cut in 2010, frozen in 2011 |
United Kingdom |
Two-year wage freeze |
Source: OECD (2011), “Restoring Public Finances”, Special issue of the OECD Journal on Budgeting, 2011/2, OECD Publishing, Paris.